91年第8期《人民音乐》发表牛龙菲同志的《民族与超越》一文(以下简称“牛文”),虽然是以“评《论音乐的超民族化》”为副标题,但却全面地评论了一个时期以来,国内有关对这篇文章的批评。看起来,牛文似乎是公正地批评了争论的双方,但实质上是对李曙明同志《论音乐的超民族化》(以下简称“李文”)的肯定、修正和补充。而对于所有批 In the article “People’s Music” published by People’s Music, “Ethnony and Transcendence” (hereinafter referred to as “Niu Wen”) by Comrade Diaoyu Philippine is an all-round Commenting on a period of time, the domestic criticism of this article. It seems that Niu Wen seems to have justly criticized both parties to the dispute, but in essence he affirmed, amended and supplemented Comrade Li Shuming’s “theory of super-nationalization of music” (hereinafter referred to as “Li Wen”). And for all lots