一位电影导演告诉我:最近他参加了一个电影座谈会,发现业余影评员的发言,十分令人扫兴:不是漫无边际地泛泛而谈,就是抓不住中心地“瞎扯”。为此,他颇为感叹地说:“记得三年前,我也在这里听过他们的发言,没想到‘别三年’,竟无多大长进！” 导演的话“一针见血”,使我陷入了沉思。寥寥数言,虽不能成为一种“定论”,却倒提醒了我们:“群众影评”的水平若仅仅停留在“群众发言”上,恐怕不仅落伍于时代,有愧于电影评论事业,而且难以进入艺术的大殿。 A film director told me: Recently he took part in a film symposium and found amateur film critics speech is very disappointing: not to be endless and general, is unable to grasp the center of “nonsense.” To this end, he quite lamented: “I remember three years ago, I also heard their speech here, did not think ’do not three years’, did not grow much!” The director’s words “sharply” caught me meditation. A few words, although not a “final conclusion,” remind us that if the level of “mass critics” only stays in the “mass speeches,” I am afraid that it will not only fall behind the times but be ashamed of the film criticism and be difficult to justify Into the art hall.