编辑先生:贵刊2005年第5期122页《汉青铜笔搁现南通》一文,称发现了我国“存世最早的青铜文具”。我觉得此文有两点值得商榷:一、此品不制于汉代而制于五代;二、是铜瓦不是铜笔搁。早年我见清冯云鹏、冯云鹓合著的《金石索》介绍过此种铜瓦。著者考证不是汉代而是五代十国中南汉的制品。公元904年, Editor: Your issue No. 5, 2005 page 122 “Han bronze pen is now on the Nantong” one article, said the discovery of China’s “surviving bronze stationery.” I think this article is worth discussing two points: First, this product is not made in the Han Dynasty and the Five Dynasties system; Second, the copper tile is not a copper pen holder. Early years I see Feng Yunpeng, Feng Yun 鹓 co-author of “stone” introduced such copper tile. Author textual research is not the Han Dynasty, but the Five Dynasties and the Five Central South Han Dynasty products. In 904 AD,