论文部分内容阅读
章太炎先生在《訄书》中提出的:“葛氏假手于吴人,以殒关羽之命”的见解虽仅是猜测,但确实很有道理。关羽发动襄樊战役前后长达半年。在此期间,魏军几乎倾巢出动,曹操先后派出五批精锐部队增援樊城。在曹魏和东吴绝对优势兵力的夹击下,关羽全军溃败,危在旦夕,他日夜企盼蜀汉救兵的到来。但直至关羽临沮被擒,刘备、诸葛亮未以一卒增援荆州。方诗铭认为这是刘备要翦锄关羽,但其理由牵强附会,绝难令人信服。除了羽、葛之间争夺权力的矛盾外,由于关羽不断破坏诸葛亮联吴抗魏的战略方针,故葛氏假吴人之手将其翦锄也就不是毫无道理之事。
Mr. Zhang Taiyan put forward in the book: “Geshi fake hand in Wu, with the Guan Yu’s life,” the opinion is only speculation, but it makes sense. Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan up to six months before and after. During this period, Wei Jun almost surrendered. Cao Cao sent five batches of elite troops to reinforce Fancheng. Under the attack of the absolutely superior forces of Cao Wei and Soochow, Guan Yu defeated the whole army at a dangerous moment, and he looked forward to the rescue of Shu troops day and night. But until Guan Yu Lin Ju captured, Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang did not reinforce Jingzhou. Fang Shi Ming believes that this is Liu Bei to hoe Guan Yu, but the reasons for forced annex, absolutely hard to be convincing. In addition to Yu, Ge contend for power between the contradictions, as Guan Yu continue to undermine the strategic direction of the joint anti-Wei Zhuge Liang, Ge Ge fake Wu hand to hoe it is not unreasonable thing.