Systematic review: The placebo effect of psychological interventions in the treatment of irritable b

来源 :World Journal of Gastroenterology | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:xmzhkj
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM To determine the placebo response rate associated with different types of placebo interventions used in psychological intervention studies for irritable bowel syndrome. METHODS Randomized controlled trials comparing psychological interventions(stress management/relaxation therapy(cognitive) behavioral therapy, short-term psychodynamic therapy, and hypnotherapy) for the treatment of adult patients with irritable bowel syndrome(IBS) diagnosed with the Manning or Rome criteria with an adequate placebo control treatment and reporting data on IBS symptom severity were identified by searching Pub Med, Embase, the Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Psyc INFO databases. Full-text articles that were written in English and published between 1966 and February 2016 in peer-reviewed journals were selected for the present review. Placebo interventions were considered to be adequate if the number of sessions and the amount of time spent with the therapist were the same as in the active treatment. The placebo response rate(PRR) was computed for IBS symptom severity(primary outcome measure) as well as for anxiety, depression and quality of life(secondary outcome measures). RESULTS Six studies, with a total of 555 patients met the inclusion criteria. Four studies used an educational intervention, whereas two studies used a form of supportive therapy as the placebo intervention. The PRR for IBS symptom severity ranged from 25% to 59%, with a pooled mean of 41.4%. The relative PRR for the secondary outcome measures ranged from 0% to 267% for anxiety, 6% to 52% for depression 20% to 125% for quality of life. The PRR associated with pharmacological treatments, treatment with dietary bran and complementary medicine ranged from 37.5% to 47%. Contrary to our expectations, the PRR in studies on psychological interventions was comparable to that in studies on pharmacological, dietary and alternative medical interventions.CONCLUSION The PRR is probably determined to a larger extent by patient-related factors, such as expectations and desire for the treatment to be effective, than the content of the placebo intervention. METHODS Randomized controlled trials comparing psychological interventions (stress management / relaxation therapy (cognitive) behavioral therapy, short-term psychodynamic therapy, and hypnotherapy) for the treatment of adult patients with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) diagnosed with the Manning or Rome criteria with an adequate placebo control treatment and reporting data on IBS symptom severity identified identified by searching Pub Med, Embase, the Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Psyc INFO databases. Full-text articles that were written in English and published between 1966 and February 2016 in peer-reviewed journals were selected for the present review. Placebo interventions were considered to be adequate if the number of sessions and the amount of time spent with the therapist were the same as in the active treatment. The p Results Six subjects, with a total of 555 patients with the inclusion criteria. Four (4), with a total of 555 patients who were eligible for anxiety, depression and quality of life (secondary outcome measures) studies used an educational intervention, while two studies used a form of supportive therapy as the placebo intervention. The PRR for IBS symptom severity ranged from 25% to 59%, with a pooled mean of 41.4%. The relative PRR for the secondary outcome measures ranged from 0% to 267% for anxiety, 6% to 52% for depression of 20% to 125% for quality of life. The PRR associated with pharmacological treatments, treatment with dietary bran and complementary medicine ranged from 37.5% to 47%. Contrary to our expectations, the PRR in studies on psychological interventions was comparable to that in studies on pharmacological, dietary and alternative medical interventions.CONCLUSION The PRR is probably determined to a larger extent by patient-related factors, such as expectations and desire for the treatment to be effective, than the content of the placebo intervention.
其他文献
适用主题:忙中偷闲的快乐;悠然心境;争夺……中午下了课,接到通知,下午四点还要参加一个会议。三点五十九分,我准时到了会场。在整整两个钟头的时间里,我和其他的人一样聆听
<正> 声音是静寂的破裂,话语使得沉默无法延续,而在话语与话语之间,则存在着短暂的话语的中止——间隔。间隔属于话语,也是沉默,或者说是话语中的沉默,沉默中的话语。
在当前关于文艺的意识形态性质的论争中,我以为应该区分两种情况:一种情况是极力鼓吹文艺的非意识形态化,主张文艺与意识形态脱钩,企图从根本上否定和推翻马克思主义的意识
目的探讨氢氧化铝致猫运动区癫痫模型的制作方法及病理、超微结构变化。方法在猫的左侧大脑乙状前回注入氢氧化铝乳剂或生理盐水50μl。术后观察猫的行为学变化,皮层脑电图变
近年来乳腺癌的术前化疗,即新辅助化疗(neoadjuvant chemotherapy,NCT)已成为乳腺癌治疗的热点[1-2 ].20世纪70年代意大利米兰肿瘤研究所首先用于治疗不可手术的局部晚期乳腺癌(locally advanced breast cancer,LABC),获得了比较理想的疗效,一些不可切除的经化疗后变为可切除。
三国时期,战乱连连,才子袁涣为躲避兵祸,流寓江淮一带,初为袁术所用,后袁术战败,袁涣成了吕布的俘虏。  吕布占据徐州后,听说刘备正在招兵买马,打算背叛自己,他便让手下从牢中唤来袁涣,要他写信去骂刘备。见袁涣不从,怒不可遏的吕布随即拔出佩刀说:“你辱骂刘备就可以活命,否则便死路一条!”面对威逼,袁涣镇定自若道:“这个世界上,真正使人受辱的是德行不足,我还没听说过挨几句骂就能让人受辱。再说,如果刘备是
由英国食品配销研究所和英国《包装周刊》共同组织的“1995年包装环保管理奖”(195Packaging Management EnvironmentalAwards)于11月间评出.该奖主要奖励那些在包装设计中有
目的 建立可以同时检测乳腺癌患者外周血中循环肿瘤细胞多个基因表达水平的悬浮阵列方法,探讨多基因联合检测在乳腺癌术后复发早期预测中的应用价值.方法 以悬浮阵列技术检测73例乳腺癌患者外周血循环肿瘤细胞癌基因,并用COX比例风险模型寻找影响乳腺癌复发转移的独立预后因素.结果 成功建立了可以同时检测乳腺癌患者外周血中8种循环肿瘤细胞基因表达水平的悬浮阵列方法,基因阳性率从大到小排列的结果为乳腺珠蛋白(h
一氧化氮和相关亚硝基化合物的神经保护与神经破坏作用的氧化还原机制一氧化氮(NO)在卒中引起的神经损伤中起重要作用;然而,在某些研究中,它又显示出神经保护作用。如何解释这种显然
为研究东海内陆架闽浙沿岸泥质区不同深度沉积物中古菌群落垂向分布特征,利用古菌16SrDNA基因文库得到473个有效克隆、50个OTUs(Operational Taxonomic Units).16SrDNA序列系