论文部分内容阅读
在1994年第一期《名作欣赏》上刊登了靳极苍先生的《评王富仁同志对宋祁〈玉楼春〉词的赏析》,同年第六期上又刊登了靳极苍先生的《对梁锡华〈鲁迅的《纪念刘和珍君》〉批评的批评》。细读靳先生两篇批评的宏文,笔者不但折服了靳先生学贯古今的博识,而且对其批评的勇气极为叹服。在如今文坛并不热闹的情况下,多一点批评,来一点商榷,不但有助于澄清学术上的迷误,更能增强文坛上的热闹气氛。鉴于此,笔者也想来凑一下热闹,对靳先生的宏文提出一点批评意见。我相信,靳先生既有提出批评的勇气,也必然有接受批评的雅量。 也许我批评的语言也是重的,但想起靳先生所言“但对沉疴用重剂,不也是该当的么?”心中倒也泰然。
In the first issue of 1994, “Appreciation of Famous Works” published Mr. Jin Jikang’s commentary on Comrade Wang Furen’s appreciation of Song Qi . In the sixth issue of the same year, he published “ Criticism of Criticism. ” Read the two texts criticized by Mr. Jin, the author not only conquered Mr. Jin learned ancient and modern knowledge, but also extremely impressed with the courage of his criticism. In today’s literary arena is not busy, a little more criticism, a little deliberation, not only helps to clarify the academic confusion, but also enhance the atmosphere of the literary atmosphere. In view of this, I also want to come and join in the lively, to Mr. Jin Hongwen a little criticism. I believe that Mr. Jin has the courage to criticize as well as the magnanimity to be criticized. Perhaps my criticism of the language is heavy, but remembered Mr. Jin said, “but heavy use of Shen, is not it deserved it?”