《新闻大学》2008年第1期发表的黄春平同志的文章《历史需要宽容还是需要真实?——关于范长江“新说法”的思考》中,谈到了有关同志与尹韵公之间的3次争鸣问题。文章中在谈到第一次争鸣时说:“这次争鸣的焦点是有关范长江的西北采访目的问题,蓝先生认为范长江‘入甘走在红军的前面,实际上起到了一个先探路、先调查研究的作用’。而尹先生认为蓝的观点不能成立。因为事实上我军没有任何范长 Journal of the University of the Press, 2008, No. 1 Published by Comrade Huang Chunping’s article, ”Does History Need to Be Tolerance or Necessity to Be True?“ In his article on ”Thoughts on Fan Changjiang’s“ New Argument, ”it talks about the relations between comrades and Yin Yun-gong Contend issue. When talking about the first contention, the article said: “The focus of this debate is on the purpose of interviews with Fan Changjiang in the northwest. Mr. Lan believes Fan Changjiang has taken the lead in the Red Army and actually played a first exploration Road, the role of the first investigation and study. ’”And Mr. Yin believes that the blue point of view can not be established because in fact we do not have any Fan long