在《台湾研究集刊》2000年第3期上，周翔鹤先生撰文《清代台湾土地开垦、经济组织和社会经济形态》，批评拙文《清代台湾拓垦过程中的股份制经营──兼论“农业资本主义萌芽”理论的不成立》。（见《中国社会科学》1998年第2期，以下简称《拓垦》）。周翔鹤先生的态度是认真的 In “Taiwan Studies Journal” No. 3, 2000, Mr. Zhou Xianghe wrote “land reclamation, economic organization and social and economic patterns in Taiwan in the Qing Dynasty” and criticized Zhuo Wen’s article “Joint-Stock Management in Taiwan’s Land Reclamation in the Qing Dynasty ──An Agriculture The sprout of capitalism ”theory is not established.“ (See ”Chinese Social Sciences“ 1998 the second period, hereinafter referred to as ”land reclamation"). Mr. Zhou Xianghe’s attitude is serious