拙稿《也谈中国近代史上的“情”与“理”》①曾从有关概念和评价方法等方面对郑剑顺先生《中国近代史上几个问题的“情”与“理”》一文②提出质疑。近读郑先生《关于“情”与“理”商榷的答复》③,不但没有消除笔者原有的疑问,反而增加了新的困惑。思忖再三,不吐不快。看来,只有从“情”与“理”两个评价标准误区中走出来,回到历史唯物主义关于道德尺度与历史尺度的标准问题讨论 I have also raised the issue of “love” and “reason” in the modern history of China ① Queries on Mr. Zheng Jianshun’s “love” and “rationale” for several issues in modern Chinese history from aspects of concepts and evaluation methods. In-depth study of Mr. Cheng’s “Reply on” Love “and” Reason “③ not only did not eliminate the author’s original questions, but added new confusion. Think again and again, do not spit fast. It seems that only from the erroneous standards of ”love“ and ”rationality" come out and return to the historical materialism’s discussion on the standard of morality and history