本文主要是对《乌克兰煤》杂志2006,№3“无人工作面开采薄煤层机组”反对论者的解释和辩论。顿巴斯煤田有70%~80%是薄煤层(0.8 m以下),而且瓦斯浓度很高。因此很需要无人工作面开采这些薄煤层。在波兰1.5 m的煤层属于薄煤层,不利于开采,不允许在这种煤层的回采工作面作业。介 This article is mainly the interpretation and debate of the oppositionists in Ukraine Coal Magazine 2006, No. 3, “Mining Thin Coal Seam Units without Surface”. 70% -80% of Donbass coalfields are thin coal seams (below 0.8 m) with high gas concentrations. Therefore, it is very necessary to mine these thin coal seams unmanned face. The 1.5 m coal seam in Poland is a thin seam that is not conducive to mining and does not allow working on the mining face of such seam. Introducing