语文课为什么一定要上成文学鉴赏课,一定要分析文章的主题呢?《鸟鸣涧》表现了怎样的思想感情,初中生能否掌握?《孙子兵法》是兵家圣典,今天可不可以把它看作生意经?《三国演义》是历史小说,能否把它当做“人才学”来读?《周易》是占卜书,还是哲学著作?《归园田居》在成年人和中学生读来,感受是否不同?对此,作者提出─— Why must the language class be a literary appreciation class? Must we analyze the theme of the article? What kind of thoughts and feelings does the “bird singing” show? Can the junior high school student grasp? The “military law of Sun Tzu” is the scripture of the military family. Can it be today? It is regarded as business classics. The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a historical novel. Can it be read as “study of talent ”? Is “Book of Changes” a book of divination or a philosophical book? “The Return of the Garden” is read by adults and middle school students. If the feelings are different, the author proposes that -