反向格义与中国哲学方法论反思

来源 :哲学研究 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:syh904
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
The traditional geyi or analogical interpretation practice purports to help Chinese understand and accept Hindu Buddhism through employing Taoist terms to interpret Buddhist terminology. Modern geyi, on the other hand, is the opposite: Western philosophical ideas are employed in the interpretation of ancient Chinese terms. Thus, we may name it fanxiang geyi or reverse analogical interpretation. However, this practice gives rise to difficulties that put even scholars in dilemmas because few Western philosophical concepts match the meaning of Chinese philosophical terms that refer to them. This paper attempts to examine the intricacy in this popular exercise through two examples. One is the long period argumentation on whether Laozi’s daodaoism is material or spiritual. The other is a deeper concern as to whether daodaoism is both metaphysical and of human value. The intricacy and arguments are generated by the divergence of Chinese and Western terminological systems, as well as of general cultural background. Therefore, we cannot find a simple correspondence between Western concepts and Chinese terms. Given this difficulty, we should explore the difference between the Western and Chinese terms and try to avoid using a ready Western term to define a Chinese expression. The traditional geyi or analogical interpretation practice purports to help Chinese understand and accept Hindu Buddhism through employing Taoist terms to interpret Buddhist terminology. Modern geyi, on the other hand, is the opposite: Western philosophical ideas are employed in the interpretation of Ancient Chinese terms. Thus, we may name it fanxiang geyi or reverse analogical interpretation. However, this practice gives rise to difficulties that put even scholars in dilemmas because few Western philosophical concepts match the meaning of Chinese philosophical terms that refer to them. This paper attempts to examine the intricacy in this popular exercise through two examples. One is the long period argumentation on whether Laozi’s daodaoism is material or spiritual. The other is a deeper concern as to whether daodaoism is both metaphysical and of human value. The intricacy and arguments are generated by the divergence of Chinese and Western terminological systems, as well as of gen Given this difficulty, we should explore the difference between the Western and Chinese terms and try to avoid using a ready Western term to define a Chinese expression.
其他文献
采用预乳化半连续种子乳液聚合方法合成了GPES保温板专用界面剂有机硅改性丙烯酸乳液。通过引入丙烯酸异辛酯(2-EHA)、甲基丙烯酸甲酯(MMA)、苯乙烯(St)和功能性单体丙烯酸(AA)和硅烷
船舶受海洋环境扰动会产生升沉、横荡、纵荡、横摇、艏摇、纵摇六个自由度的运动,严重影响船上设备的正常工作。通常船舶的艏摇、横荡、纵荡三个自由度运动可通过动力定位系
当我们远古的祖先遥望着星空时,见那满天星斗,或大或小,或灿烂闪烁,或暗淡无光,或运行不息,或静止不动,而且还发现,这些神秘的星星对气候有着明显的影响,与他们的生存息息相关。他们不
随着再生能源和分布式发电的发展,并网逆变器及其入网电流控制策略受到越来越多的关注和研究。本文以单相并网逆变器的入网电流谐波抑制控制为主要研究内容,介绍了自适应重复
目的 :由于人参皂苷Rb1、Re各自大鼠体内的口服生物利用度都比较低,分别为0.78%、7.71%。为了提高它们的生物利用度,本研究将人参皂苷Rb1、Re进行组合用药,研究其在SD大鼠体
通过流动度、需水量比、胶砂活性指数、混凝土工作性及抗压强度试验,建立一元回归方程,研究了微珠对C60高强商品混凝土性能的影响。结果表明:微珠能提高混凝土的早期强度;随微珠
'形势与政策'课作为高校学生思想政治教育的重要组成部分,在大学生思想政治教育中担负着重要使命,具有不可替代的作用。因此针对'形势与政策'课是对大学生进