Locking plate versus external fixation for type C distal radius fractures:A meta-analysis of randomi

来源 :中华创伤杂志(英文版) | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:xiang88_77
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Purpose:Distal radial fracture is one of the most common fractures.Up to now,locking plates (LP) and extal fixation (EF) are two conventional surgical approaches to type C radius fracture.Which method is superior has not yet reached a consensus.We try to assess the clinical effectiveness of the two interventions by this meta-analysis.Methods:We used network to search the PubMed,Embase,and Cochrane Medical Library of randomized controlled clinical trials about the type C distal radius fractures performed according to the search strategy mentioned in Cochrane Handbook 5.1.0 from Jan.2005 to Jan.2016.Patients in the experimental group were used LP,in the control group were included EF and other surgical approaches.Publication language was restricted to English.Studies that patient population and surgical indication did not define had been excluded.Studies must report at least one of the outcomes as follow:radial inclination,palmar tilt,ulnar variance,range of wrist flexion and extension,and range of wrist supination and pronation.The trials in which participants included children were excluded.We used Jadad study scores to appraise the study.Results:Seven studies included 162 patients (LP group) and 190 patients (EF group).We compared the radial inclination,palmar tilt,ulnar variance,range of wrist flexion and extension,and range of wrist supination and pronation.The radial inclination were revealed a difference favoring LP over EF [WMD =1.84,95% CI (0.17,3.50),p =0.03] and the palmar tilt and ulnar variance was no significant difference between the two groups [(WMD =3.61,95% CI(0.00,7.23),p =0.05;WMD =0.05,95% CI (-0.99,1.09),p =0.93].The functional activities of range of flexion and extension and range of supination and pronation between the two groups was no difference [WMD =10.04,95% CI (-6.88,26.96),p =0.24;WMD =12.53,95% CI (-9.99,35.06),p =0.28].Conclusion:Locking plate and extal fixation is feasible to heal radius type C fracture.We found the small difference between the two groups on imaging examination.The locking plate has the advantage on maintaining reduction,however no significant difference regarding outcomes has been found between the two groups.
其他文献
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
期刊
由于江苏电信电子邮箱系统,因合作方原因退网,电子邮箱chxj.jy@public.tz.js.cn将于2013年2月28日24时停止服务,今后联系请用chxj.jy@163.com邮箱和sensor@jiangfen.com.cn邮
2013年5月28-29日,生活用纸国际研讨会在深圳会展中心举行,爱生雅(SCA)公司Stephan Dyckerhoff博士做了题为《为失禁人群提供更好的关护》的演讲,本刊根据录音将其整理成文发表,供
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
期刊
所谓直接缫丝是指不通过煮茧工序而进行真空渗透处理后直接送到缫丝工场进行缫制.目前,四川省的缫丝工厂多采取此方法[l],笔者对该省丝厂考察发现,直接缫丝不仅仅是一些企业
笔者采用益肾活血汤配合胰岛素治疗糖尿病肾病,通过临床观察,收效良好,现报道如下.rn1 临床资料rn60例患者均按WHO诊断标准确诊为糖尿病,且符合下列条件:①尿蛋白阳性,24h尿
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
期刊
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
期刊
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
期刊