拍卖作为一种交易架构,从本质上来说是一整套程序,它由若干不同但相互关联的程序结合而成,每一个单独的程序都关乎整个拍卖活动的正常运行。在拍卖实务中,一些程序性问题经常引起争议,关于这些程序性问题的争议甚至已经影响到整个拍卖活动的效力。本文将这些看似细小但至关重要的程序进行梳理,希望能为实践提供些许可行性建议。 Auction as a transactional structure is essentially a set of procedures. It consists of several different but interrelated procedures. Each individual procedure is related to the normal operation of the whole auction. In the auction practice, some procedural issues are often controversial, and the controversy over these procedural issues has even affected the effectiveness of the entire auction. The paper sorts out these seemingly small but vital processes and hopes to provide some practical advice on how to do that.