论人事诉讼中辩论主义与职权探知主义的协同模式

来源 :甘肃政法学院学报 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:jiangyao366
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
人事诉讼对象的非处分性造就了人事诉讼中应对辩论主义和处分权主义的适用加以限制,广泛适用职权探知制度。实行职权探知主义的根据在于人事诉讼判决具有对世效力,以维系身份法秩序的稳定,保护未行使审问请求权的第三人的合法权益。伴随传统的职权主义被当事人主义所取代,以当事人为主导的诉讼模式在我国逐步确立,普通诉讼程序法理不仅难以满足人事诉讼案件审判实践的需要,同时无法实现二者的调和。文章认为设立专门人事诉讼程序,构建一种辩论主义与职权探知主义兼容的协同模式,才能从根本上解决当事人主义对人事诉讼裁判带来的冲击。人事诉讼中诉讼与非讼法理交错适用,普通诉讼程序法理难以满足这一要求,构建既有别于普通诉讼程序,又不同于非讼程序的独立人事诉讼程序乃是客观之必然。 The non-disposition of the object of personnel litigation creates the restriction of the application of the debate doctrine and the disposition right in the personnel litigation, and applies the system of the system of ex officio authority. The basis of the implementation of the exploratory power of causation lies in the fact that the judgments of personnel litigation are effective against the world in order to maintain the stability of the law of the law of identity and protect the lawful rights and interests of the third party who has the right to interrogation not exercised. With the traditional power of attorney being replaced by the doctrine of litigation, litigation mode dominated by the parties gradually established in our country, the common lawsuit legal not only difficult to meet the needs of judicial trial of personnel litigation cases, and can not achieve the reconciliation of the two. The article holds that the establishment of a special procedure for personnel affairs and the establishment of a collaborative model compatible with the debate on doctrine and functional exploration of causation can fundamentally resolve the impact of litigantism on the judicial review of personnel litigation. Personnel litigation litigation and non-litigation jurisprudence apply, common lawsuit jurisprudence difficult to meet this requirement, to establish both separate from ordinary litigation, but also different from the non-litigation process of independent personnel proceedings objectively is inevitable.
其他文献
特许经营,是国际流行的一种商业理念,已有一百多年的发展历史,自20世纪90年代进入我国后发展迅速,但在学术界和立法中都相当滞后,本文基于民法理论对特许经营和特许经营权予
曹雪芹在对人、事进行描述时很喜欢使用比喻句.在使用比喻句时,他主要用"……一般"和"……似的"两种格式."……一般"的比喻句非常贴切、别致、生动、形象,体现了曹雪芹作为伟
作为魏晋"正始之音"的代表,嵇康可谓继往开来、雄视一代的人物,有着独特的人生,不同凡响的艺术追求.他既重视对前代文学遗产的继承,更注重创作上的开拓创新.他文备众体,成就
垄断规制的复杂性与反垄断规则的不确定性决定了反垄断执法具有很大的弹性,而反垄断执法机构则具有广泛的自由裁量权。反垄断执法失范和自由裁量权滥用会给相对人利益造成极大
网络文学作品在形态、美学标准、结构以及自我意识等各方面,都与传统文学作品有极大的不同.通过对二者的比较,对网络文学作品在标题、语言、内容的价值选择上呈现出的特点加
文章对鲁迅提出的"文学的自觉时代"追本溯源,按迹寻踪的作了翔实的回顾.通过"摆脱巫文化的束缚""摆脱文人的垄断""注入市民精神"的论述,引出中国文学史上至少出现过四次文学