在我国法治建设的初级阶段,以理服人的判决具有重要作用。本文主要对山东省某些地方法院司法论证运作实践进行调研,对司法论证的主体、标准、方法及限度等内容做了一定深入的介绍与分析。由此表明,我国司法论证的实践运作呈现出较为复杂的局面。很多问题无法笼统地用似是而非的说法去概括,而是需要做具体分析。 In the initial stage of the rule of law in our country, judgments based on serving the people play an important role. This paper mainly investigates the operation of judicial argumentation in some local courts in Shandong Province, and introduces and analyzes the subject, standards, methods and limits of judicial argumentation in depth. This shows that the practice of judicial argumentation in our country shows a more complicated situation. Many problems can not be generalized in plausible terms, but need to be analyzed in concrete terms.