论文部分内容阅读
法学方法的产生与创新不是源自法学方法本身的研究,而是源自法学所研究的问题本身。法学方法的运用是以法律问题的研究为前提和基础,主要起到技术辅助作用。一旦脱离了具体问题研究,法学方法论必将陷入教条主义泥潭,不仅危及法学方法,而且危及运用法学方法加以论证的问题及相关学科。经济法学界隐含着偏重法学方法论倾向,容易异化新型法学方法,不但不能有效解决经济法学困境,有时反而进一步加剧困扰。无论传统法学方法还是新型法学方法本身并没有错误,问题在于如何对待法学方法论。经济法学困境实质上不是经济法学所要研究的内容本身,而是形式问题。过分拔高法学方法论,只会助长形式问题。经济法学困境突围关键在于经济法学界学术态度的转型。
The emergence and innovation of legal method originated not from the research of legal method itself, but from the problem studied by law. The application of legal methods is based on the study of legal issues as the basis and mainly plays the role of technical assistance. Once detachment from the study of specific issues, jurisprudence methodology is bound to fall into the quagmire of dogmatism, not only endanger the legal method, but also endanger the use of jurisprudence to prove the problem and related disciplines. Economic law circles have the tendency to emphasize the methodology of jurisprudence and easily alienate the new method of law. They not only can not effectively solve the dilemma of economic law, but sometimes further aggravate the troubles. There is no mistake either in traditional jurisprudence or in new jurisprudence itself, and the question is how to treat jurisprudence. The dilemma of economic law is essentially not the content to be studied by economic law, but the formal problem. Excessive elevation of jurisprudence methodology can only encourage formal problems. The key to breaking the dilemma of economic law lies in the transformation of academic attitude in economic law circles.