读了《美苑》2003年第4期上陈传席先生的文章《谈批评和危机及轻批评问题》(以下简称“陈文”),颇有些不以为然。因事关学术,不敢缄默,也来谈一点对艺术批评的见解。 陈文先是以考据的方法,从词源学上将批评(Criticize或Criticism)与危机(Crisis)联系起来,得出“看来‘批评’和‘危机’真的有密不可分关系”的结论;继而又通过对大量史实(如唐诗、宋词、清代绘画等艺术现象)的列举,再次得出结论说,“看来,批评 After reading the article “On Criticism, Crisis and Light Criticism” (hereinafter referred to as “Chen Wen”) published by Chen Chuanxi in No. 4, 2003, “Mei Yuan Yuan”, there is quite a bit disapproved. Because of the academic, not silent, but also to talk about the views of art criticism. Based on the etymology, Criticize or Criticism and Crisis, Chen Wenxian used the textual research method to conclude that “it seems that criticism and the crisis are really inextricably linked” Then through the enumeration of a large number of historical facts (such as Tang poetry, Song Ci, Qing Dynasty painting and other art phenomenon), once again concluded that "It seems that criticism