《刑事辩护的中国经验》田文昌陈瑞华著北京大学出版社书评我常对某些律师朋友开玩笑说,最好的辩护意见,就是法官会大篇幅“侵犯”律师著作权的意见。在法庭上,法官只是倾听者,而在庭外,由于承办法官要与合议庭其他成员或者审委会成员交流、讨论,有时还得扮演说服者的角色 “China’s Experience in Criminal Defense” Tian Wenchang Chen Ruihua Peking University Press Book reviews I often joke against some lawyers and friends that the best defense is the judge’s long comments on “infringement” of a lawyer’s copyright. In court, the judge is only a listener, and outside the court, as a judge to be with other members of the collegial panel or the Committee members to discuss, and sometimes have to play the role of persuader