国家知识产权局专利复审委员会、浙江今飞机械集团有限公司与浙江万丰摩轮有限公司专利无效行政利纷案(简称“万丰摩托车轮案”)是最高人民法院精选出作为《最高人民法院知识产权案件年度报告》(2010)示范指导案例之一。特别的,本案讨论了两大外观设计计专利制度的基本问题:外观设计专利相同或近似的判断主体和设计空间。对此,本文将进行细致地分析和讨论。以下首先综述相关的法律事实和各审法院的法律意 Patent Prosecution Board of State Intellectual Property Office, Zhejiang Jinfei Machinery Group Co., Ltd. and Zhejiang Wanfeng Wheel Co., Ltd. Patent invalid Administrative Litigation (hereinafter referred to as “Wanfeng Motorcycle Wheel Case”) was selected by the Supreme People’s Court as a “ Supreme People’s Court Annual Report on Intellectual Property Cases ”(2010) one of the model guidance. In particular, the case discusses the basic issues of the two grand designs of patent systems: the same or similar appearance of design patents and design space. In this regard, this article will be detailed analysis and discussion. The following is a summary of the relevant legal facts and the legal implications of the trial courts