王无析(影视剧本讲习班主任):《神鞭》拍得很好有很大娱乐性。正如导演张子恩所说,这是一部“历史寓言故事”,艺术性比较完整。有些武打片胡编滥造,题材雷同,看头知尾,没有思考的余地。《神鞭》抛弃了陈规旧套,有自己的艺术特点,把娱乐性、艺术性和哲理性结合起来,使主题有强烈的象征意义。影片的不足是前半部分精彩,结尾没有份量。玻璃花这个人物交待不够清楚。片 Wang no analysis (film script workshop director): “God Whip” is very good and very entertaining. As the director Zhang Zien said, this is a “history fable story”, artistic integrity. Some martial arts films are abusive, the same themes, see the beginning and tail, there is no room for thinking. “God whip” abandoned the stereotypes, have their own artistic features, entertainment, art and philosophy together, so that the theme has a strong symbolic meaning. The lack of video is the first half of the wonderful, there is no weight at the end. Glass flower this character is not clear enough. sheet