2014年,本刊发表了黄金的来稿《沦陷前后张庭济与“奉命维持”的北平故宫博物院事业》。该文为作者硕士论文的一部分,发表前按照本刊匿名审稿制度,已请熟悉该段历史的学者审读并同意发表,刊载于《院刊》2014年第5期。出版后,该文获得了学界广泛的关注,曾任故宫博物院副院长的于坚先生对该文的某些学术观点提出了不同的看法,并撰文《对黄金文章的几点意见》,现刊载于此,供原文作者及读者参考比较,并传达本刊对严谨学风之倡导。 In 2014, the magazine published a contribution from Gold that “Zhang Tingji and” before and after the fall of the People’s Republic of China ordered the maintenance of the “Beiping Palace Museum”. This article is part of the author’s master’s thesis. Before publication, according to the anonymous reviewing system of this journal, scholars familiar with the history have been invited to review and agree to publish it and publish it in the 5th issue of the journal. After its publication, the article received wide attention in the academic field. Former Vice Minister of the National Palace Museum, Mr. Yu Jian put forward some different opinions on some academic points of the article and wrote the article “Several Opinions on Gold Articles” Is published here for reference and comparison of the original author and reader, and to convey the journal’s advocacy of rigorous style of study.