《炎黄春秋》2005年第4期发表了龚育之《关于〈陈独秀往事〉的一封信》(以下简称“龚序”),据该刊编者按语,“龚序”是即将出版的靳树鹏《陈独秀往事》的“代序”。“龚序”中说:“这封信主要是想同你(指靳树鹏———引者)讨论、请教三个问题”。其第一个问题是对我写于1998年 “Yan Huang Chun Qiu” 2005 the fourth issue of Gong Yu’s “about” Chen Duxiu past “a letter” (hereinafter referred to as “Gong Xu”), according to the editor’s memoir, “Gong Xu” is the forthcoming Jin Shupeng “Chen Duxiu past ”“ Preface. ” “Gong Xu,” said: “This letter is mainly intended to discuss with you (referring to Jinshu Peng --- cited), ask three questions.” The first question was written to me in 1998