丧失气节和艺术缺陷并非张资平的全部。张资平小说的时代意义、艺术价值和艺术风格以及他对中国现代情爱叙事领域所带来的新视域和写作模式,值得从学理角度给予正面评判。学界将他定性为新文学作家,并以新文学的特质去比对其小说的艺术问题,而无视他本人对其小说读者的定位,是有不当之处的。研究张资平对于我们理解革命文学、海派文学和通俗文学之间的绞缠关系是大有裨益的。 Loss of integrity and artistic flaws are not all of Zhang Ziping. The epoch, artistic value and artistic style of Zhang Ziping’s novels and his new vision and writing mode brought by the narrative field of modern love in China deserve positive judgment from the academic perspective. The academic circles characterize him as a new literary writer and compared the artistic characteristics of his novels with the characteristics of the new literature, ignoring his own position on the readers of his novels. Studying Zhang Ziping is of great help to our understanding of the twisted relations between revolutionary literature, Shanghai literature and popular literature.