论文部分内容阅读
优秀学术论文是学术写作的风向标,评选优秀学术论文意义十分重大,但针对如何评选优秀学术论文鲜有较为公允的标准操作程序。《中国针灸》编辑部结合自身情况与条件,采用数据检索、编辑部会议、专家问卷调查及专家论文评审会等手段相结合的方式,从2014年《中国针灸》已发表的全部395篇论文中评选出3篇优秀学术论文。整个论文评选流程体现了“认文不认人”、主观客观相结合和关键问题一票否决三大特点。优秀学术论文产生的过程中还存在被引频次、下载频次客观数据所占比重偏大,易遗漏“曲高和寡”的优秀学术论文等偏倚,以后将进一步结合专家意见,优化完善评选流程,最终形成一套较为规范、全面的标准操作程序,向标准化、规范化靠齐。
Outstanding scholarly writing is the benchmark for academic writing. It is of great importance to select excellent scholarly papers, but there are few standard operating procedures that are relatively fair for selecting excellent scholarly papers. In combination with its own conditions and conditions, the editorial department of “Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion” adopts the methods of data retrieval, editorial board meeting, expert questionnaire survey and expert paper review meeting, and from all the 395 published papers in China Acupuncture 2014 Selected three outstanding academic papers. The entire essay selection process embodies the three characteristics of “recognizing people ”, subjective and objective combination of one-vote veto and key issues. In the process of producing excellent academic papers, there are still some biases such as excellent citations of citation frequency, objective frequency of download frequency being too large, easy to miss “high and low”, and further optimizing the process of selection by combining experts’ opinions in the future, finally Form a set of more standardized and comprehensive standard operating procedures, to standardize and standardize by Qi.