对于重伤害承诺是否有效,张明楷教授持无效说,黎宏教授采有效说,二者虽表面相异,却没有本质不同。黎宏教授的危及生命的重伤害行为的杀人故意的观点应予采纳。一般的重伤害的承诺无效。对一般的重伤害行为的处罚,可以在原来的基础上降一格,以达到不同情形间法定刑的协调。 Professor Zhang Mingkai said that Professor Li Mingkui’s use of invalidation is valid for Professor Hu Jintao’s claim that the two have different appearances but are not fundamentally different. Professor Li Hong’s intentional murder intentions of life-threatening injuries should be adopted. General heavy injury commitment is invalid. The penalties for common injuries can be reduced from the original ones to achieve the coordination of legal sentences in different situations.