一我曾听过一堂作文指导的公开课。沪版初中语文书中有“学会质疑”这一内容。可惜那位老师在课堂上始终未能举出一个例子告诉学生什么是质疑。我想,如果我是一名学生,上了这堂课,对什么是质疑还是稀里糊涂的,更别说对质疑能力的培养了。我还曾遇到过一件事。有个学生对吴晗的《谈骨气》这篇课文质疑,可他的老师却批评说是“钻牛 I have heard an open essay directed class. Shanghai version of junior high school language books have ”learn to question “ this content. Unfortunately, the teacher in the classroom has always been unable to give an example to tell students what is questioning. I think if I was a student and went to the class, I was still confused about what was questioned, let alone cultivated the ability to question. I have encountered one more thing. A student questioned Wu Han’s ”talkative“ article, but his teacher criticized it as saying, ”Drilling cattle