论文部分内容阅读
麦克道威尔试图恢复概念和世界之间的平衡,一定程度上恢复经验的证成作用。在《心灵与世界》一书中,麦氏不满于戴维森只在概念和世界之间保留因果联系,否定经验的证成作用;他还怀疑戴维森在概念和世界之间建立了一种新的二元论。相比之下,戴维森更看到自己与麦克道威尔的相同或相似之处。戴维森哲学实际上保留了对世界的谈论,戴维森所谓的信念就相当于麦克道威尔的经验概念,语言性的信念是直接关于世界的,戴维森因此并未建立任何形态的二元论。麦氏和戴维森两人思想的相同之处远甚于相异之处。
McDowell tried to restore the balance between concepts and the world, to a certain extent, to restore the proof of experience. In The Mind and the World, McGrady was dissatisfied with Davidson’s proof of preserving causality and negation of experience only between concepts and the world. He also doubted Davidson’s establishment of a new dualism between concepts and the world . In contrast, Davidson sees more or less the same or similarities with McDowell. Davidson’s philosophy actually retained the talk about the world. Davidson’s so-called belief is equivalent to McDowell’s concept of experience. The belief in language is directly related to the world. Therefore, Davidson did not establish any duality of forms. The similarities between Maxwell’s and Davidson’s ideas far outweigh the differences.