二高桥芳郎先生从另一角度否定明清时期历次“雇工人”条例反映雇佣劳动者的法律身份解放过程。他的《明末清初奴婢、雇工人等级的重修和特点》一文,认为明清两代对雇工人条例的修改,只是对“由于种种原因形成的私人支配隶属关系下的私人隶属民的法律身份,结合实际情况进行整序 From another perspective, Mr. Takahashi Takahashi denied that the “hired workers” regulations in the Ming and Qing Dynasties reflected the process of liberating the legal status of wage-workers. His article “The Menstruck in the Late Ming and Early Qing Dynasties and the Reconstruction and Characteristics of Hired Workers’ Ranks” argues that the revision of the regulations on the hired workers in the Ming and Qing dynasties only changed the "law of private subordinates under the private dominance affiliation formed by various reasons Identity, combined with the actual situation of the order