有人说,现在的博士生不如过去的硕士生,现在的硕士生不如过去的本科生,现在的本科生不如过去的专科生,而现在的专科生,也就是过去高中生的水平。这种“今不如昔”的说法固然显得片面、主观,但也在一定程度上反映了目前研究生教育的某种现状。拿音乐教育来说,我们看看30年前改革开放后的中国艺术研究院最前两届音乐学硕士研究生,现在几乎个个是学术泰斗,今天的博士毕业生又有几个将来有望能与之比肩的呢? Some people say that current doctoral students are not as good as past master’s students. Now, master’s students are inferior to past undergraduates. Nowadays undergraduates are not as good as past college students, and now junior college students, that is, former high school students. This kind of “not as good as the past” is certainly one-sided, subjective, but also to some extent, reflects some of the current status of graduate education. Take music education, we look at 30 years ago after the reform and opening up of the Chinese Academy of Arts, the first two master’s degree in music, now almost all academic leaders, today’s Ph.D. graduate there are several in the future is expected to be Shoulder to shoulder it?