本文提供了一个关于布劳格对“斯拉法主义”的各种不同抨击的整体评论,驳斥了他许多自相矛盾及与事实相悖的观点和评论,并指出他在最近的一篇文章中有一个重大的转向,即应当在严密性与关联性之间权衡取舍。作者赞同一项经济研究如欲获得尊重,它就应当既符合严密性,也符合关联性。 This article provides an overall review of Bragg’s various criticisms of Srapham, dismisses many of his contradictory and factually contrary opinions and commentary, and points out that in a recent article There is a major shift in the article that trade-offs should be made between rigor and relevance. The author agrees that if an economic study is to be respected, it should be both rigorous and associative.