前几年有人写文章,说《金瓶梅》是湖南人写的,今年又有人写文章说《红楼梦》是湖南人写的。想为湖南人争这个光的,未必就是湖南人,不过标新立异,自创新说而已。创新说,不反对,但要推倒旧说,总得有充分的证据。梁启超氏说到清代“朴学”的特色时,第一条就是“凡立一义,必凭证据; A few years ago someone wrote an article saying that “Jin Ping Mei” was written by a native of Hunan Province. This year someone wrote an article saying that “Dream of Red Mansions” was written by a native of Hunan Province. Hunan people want to fight for this light, may not be from Hunan, but unconventional, new ideas only. Innovation says, no objection, but to overthrow the old saying, there must be sufficient evidence. When Liang Qichao said of the Qing Dynasty “Pu study” of the characteristics, the first is that "whatever stands righteousness, we must evidence;