《水浒传》、《金瓶梅》和《红楼梦》是明清时期极为出色的章回小说,金圣叹等人对它们的点评水准也非常之高,并且有不少相似的观点。本文结合文本,梳理的是金圣叹、张竹坡与脂砚斋对于“犯”概念的讨论。明末崇祯年间至清初顺治、康熙年间,小说评点著作层出不穷,其中不乏精品,如金圣叹评点《水浒传》、毛宗冈评点《三国演义》、张竹坡评点《金瓶梅》 Outlaws of the Marsh, Jin Ping Mei and A Dream of Red Mansions, which were excellent chapters in the Ming and Qing Dynasties, were also very high standard by Jin Shengtan et al., And there were quite a few similar views. This article combines the text, combing the discussion of Jin Shengtang, Zhang Zhupo and Zhi Yanzhai for “guilty ” concept. During the Ming Dynasty Emperor Chongzhen to Qing Dynasty Junji, Emperor Kangxi years, the novel review works endless, many of them excellent, such as Jin Shengtan comment on “Outlaws of the Marsh”, Mao Zonggang reviews “The Romance of the Three Kingdoms”, Zhang Zhupo reviews “Golden Lotus”