2007年9月,商标评审委员会先后就两起执行生效判决重审裁定的商标争议案件,收到北京市第一中级人民法院的应诉通知,商标确权程序中再现“循环诉讼”。在第1211919号“天涯海角”商标争议、行政诉讼案中,一审判决认为“天涯海角”经过宣传使用, In September 2007, the Trademark Review and Adjudication Board successively received two notices of responding to the first Intermediate People’s Court of Beijing on the two cases of trademark dispute that brought into effect the review of the verdicts of judgment, and reappeared “circulation litigation” in the trademark right confirmation proceeding. In No. 1211919 “End of the World” trademark dispute and administrative litigation, the judgment of the first instance held that “the ends of the earth”