A critical comparison of green building rating systems

来源 :建筑节能 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:tosying11
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Various green rating systems are established globally to evaluate the sustainability of construction projects. Their categories and criteria have been under constant updates to follow the sustainable trend of building development. This paper aims to develop a systematic review of the development of green rating systems. The specific objectives are: 1) discover how interest and research in green rating systems have developed; 2) identify the similarity,difference,strength and weakness of green rating systems;3) examine whether they fully assess the projects in all aspects of sustainability. Specifically,LEED( Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design),BREEAM( Building Research Establishment Assessment Method),CASBEE( Comprehensive Assessment Systemfor Building Environmental Efficiency) and Green Star NZ were analysed in this paper. The results indicate that BREEAM,LEED, and CASBEE have been utilized since late the 2000 s while Green Star NZ is still in its earlier stages. 70%of the research papers focusing on BREEAM,LEED,CASBEE are developed geographically in the USA,Canada, the UK,China, and Australia. Although these four rating systems were initiated in different contexts with different standards, Indoor Environment Quality,Energy,and Material are core common categories for all. Environmental concerns are the main focus in New Construction manuals while Society is emphasized in Neighbourhood Development manuals. Currently,BREEAM has been the only tool which could assess all four sustainable factors. Further in-depth research is anticipated to focus more on economic and institutional factors to improve the capability of green rating systems for sustainability assessment purposes. Various green rating systems are established globally to evaluate the sustainability of construction projects. Their categories and criteria have been under constant updates to follow the sustainable trend of building development. This paper aims to develop a systematic review of the development of green rating systems. The specific objectives are: 1) discover how interest and research in green rating systems have developed; 2) identify the similarity, difference, strength and weakness of green rating systems; 3) examine whether they fully assess the projects in all aspects of sustainability , LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design), BREEAM (Building Research Establishment Assessment Method), CASBEE (Comprehensive Assessment System for Building Environmental Efficiency) and Green Star NZ were analyzed in this paper. The results indicate that BREEAM, LEED, and CASBEE have been utilized since late the 2000 s while Green Star NZ is still in its earlier stages. 70% of the research papers focusing on BREEAM, LEED, CASBEE are developed geographically in the USA, Canada, the UK, China, and Australia. Although these four rating systems were initiated in different contexts with different standards, Indoor Environment Quality, Energy, and Material are core Common concerns for all. Environmental concerns are the main focus in New Construction manuals while Society is emphasized in Neighborhood Development manuals. Currently, BREEAM has been the only tool which could assess all four sustainable factors. Further in-depth research is anticipated to focus more on economic and institutional factors to improve the capability of green rating systems for sustainability assessment purposes.
其他文献
机械工业部给排水技术情报网委托我院筹备的《高层建筑给排水设计经验座谈会》及《高层建筑给排水设备、器材小型展览会》,在机械工业部设计研究总院的热情关怀及全国给排水
目前,UG—35/39风力机械抛煤炉普遍存在着后拱二次风管使用时间不长就损坏的缺陷。不仅降低了锅炉效率,而且造成了一定的经济损失和不必要的检修费用。原后拱二次风管设计在
报导了1Cr18Ni9Ti不锈钢的连铸工艺制度及铸坯中大型夹杂物的形貌、来源及分布,以及对轧材质量的影响。通过显微观察,发现铸坯中的大型夹杂物多为TiN加球形卷渣。X—射线结构
请下载后查看,本文暂不支持在线获取查看简介。 Please download and view, this article does not support online access to view profile.
期刊
本文从职专院校的生源现状和学生学习能力入手论证在职专语文教学过程中实施小组合作学习模式的必要性并明确指出实施小组合作学习的策略要求。 This paper discusses the n
3.4 管子磨损率的空间分布如前所述,管子的磨损率沿周向和轴向都是不均匀的。对于管子破裂有实际影响意义的应该是最大的局部磨损率而不是平均磨损率。因此,了解磨损率在空
1 引言广西合山电厂#3炉是1973年制造的SG130-3.92/450型煤粉锅炉,该炉的额定蒸发量为130T/H,过热器出口蒸汽温度为450℃,压力为3.92MPa,汽包工作压力为4.31MPa,温度为250℃
该医院位于沈阳市大东区万泉公园北面,占地面积4.5公顷。医院设计规模为500张病床、1000门诊人次,因用地紧张病房楼设计为高层。 本楼建筑面积为15860米~2,平面为一字型,地
近年来的改革实践表明,高水平的经营管理人才的匾乏,是制约我国企业改革顺利推进的最大障碍之一。要搞好国有企业,必须加快选拔和培育一批现代职业型企业经营者。然而,传统的企业
混凝土的抗渗性能常以混凝土抵抗压力水渗透的能力来衡量,工程上常用“抗渗标号”来评价。目前,我国的标准试验方法是采用直径150毫米、高150毫米的圆柱体或底面直径185毫米