编辑初审作为三审制度的第一道关口,责任重大。科技期刊编辑对于各学科特点及科技论文论证方法、写作范式较为熟悉,本文认为应将这种编辑思维的优势融入初审过程中,从科技论文的写作范式入手并以科学论证为基础,从验证手段、方法对比、结果分析、结论的意义几个方面对来稿进行初审,考察论文的学术创新性。只有做好工作笔记,反复对比实践,才能获得更好的初审效果。 Editing the first instance As the first pass of the third instance system, a heavy responsibility. Editors of sci-tech periodicals are familiar with the characteristics of various disciplines and the demonstration methods and writing paradigms of sci-tech papers. This paper argues that the advantages of editorial thinking should be incorporated into the first instance process. Based on the writing paradigm of scientific papers and based on scientific evidence, , Comparison of methods, results analysis, the significance of the conclusions of several aspects of manuscripts for the first instance to examine the academic innovation of the paper. Only do a good job of notes, repeated comparative practice, in order to obtain better results of the first instance.