苏发祥著《清代治藏政策研究》一书专设一章讨论清末西藏新政,欲图对当前研究纠偏补谬,其精神虽值得佩服,但其研究却存在较大偏差:其中有常识的缺失,也有语言逻辑的混乱;而且不惜论与据的严重脱节,或无视“当时的具体历史条件”来迁就他先入为主的否定思路,故其极欲创新的意图并没得到完全实现。该章中的相关问题及其体现出的治史方法是值得商榷的。 A book devoted to the study of Tibet’s policy of governing Tibet in the Qing Dynasty was devoted to discussing the New Deal of Tibet in the late Qing Dynasty. Although its spirit is worth to be admired, its research has great deviations: among them, there are common sense Lacking and confusion in the logic of language. At the same time, they ignored the “serious historical conditions at that time” and neglected his preconceived ideas of neglect. Therefore, his intention to innovate has not been fully realized. The relevant issues in this chapter and the methods of governing history are debatable.