2004年第11、12期《乐器》杂志分两次刊载了李祥霆先生撰写的《关于明琴“寒泉漱石”的思辨》这篇考证鉴定文章, 我仔细地认真拜读了很多遍,许多方面未敢苟同。窃以为,李祥霆先生的演奏技艺卓然成家,令人佩服!但作为一篇鉴定文字,李先生的《关于明琴“寒泉漱石”的思辨》这篇文章则可以商榷之处甚多。文物鉴定颇类定案,首重证据,次重论证严密,考据详实,最忌以想象作依 In 2004, No. 11 and 12, “Musical Instruments” magazine published in two times, Mr. Li Xiangting wrote “On the Mingqin” cold spring Socks “speculation article, I carefully read carefully many times, in many ways did not dare Agree. Stealing the thought that Mr. Li Xiangting’s playing skill Zoran’s family was admirable! However, as an appraisal script, Mr. Li’s article on ”Speculation about Hanming Sommit" of Mingqin can be consulted a lot. Appraisal of cultural relics quite similar to the verdict, the first evidence, the second argument rigorously, the test is detailed, the most avoid imagination