批评家年会我算是全勤者之一,参加了从2007年的第一届到今年的第六届。原因主要是,我把年会看作和批评圈新老朋友一年一聚的团圆饭,虽没指望它有什么学术高度和引领作用,也不觉得其乐融融有什么不好。至于把在年会上敢批判敢斗争,当作一种道德勇气和知识分子责任,我更是不以为然。因为现在有多种公开表达反对意见的渠道,比如说博客和微博,有各种社会问题体现批评家的道德勇气和知识分子责任心。至于其他与会者怎么想,那是他们的事情,也是他们的个人权利。 Critics of the annual meeting I regarded as one of the attendants, participated in the first from 2007 to the sixth this year. The main reason is that I regard the annual meeting as a reunion dinner for criticizing the new and old friends for a whole year. Although I do not expect any academic heights and leading roles, I do not think it is good or bad. As for taking the responsibility of criticizing and daring to struggle at the annual meeting as a kind of moral courage and intellectual responsibility, I even disagree. Because there are various channels for publicly expressing objections, such as blogs and Weibo, there are various social problems that reflect the moral courage and intellectual responsibility of critics. As for what other participants think, it is their business and their personal rights.