Traditional Chinese herbal medicine for vascular dementia

来源 :中国药理学与毒理学杂志 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:zhougtz
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
OBJECTIVE To systematically review the clinical efficacy and safety on TCHMs that are used for vascular dementia(VaD).METHODS To identify studies for systematical review,electronic searches were performed through several databases-ALOIS,CNKI,CBM,Weipu,Wanfang,etc.Only randomized control trials(RCTs)or controlled clinical trials(CCTs)were included.Patients were diagnosed with VaD by diagnostic criteria(DSM,NINDS-AIREN,ICD or HIS)as well as imaging technique(CT,MRI or functional imaging,etc).Eligible TCHMs must be recognized in the Chinese Pharmacopeia or the National Essential Drug List of the People′s Republic of China.Included studies were appraised using the Cochrane Collaboration risk-of-bias criteria.Efficacy and safety outcomes were evaluated by meta-analysis.Efficacy outcomes include cognition,daily function,global performance and behaviour;safety was assessed by the number of adverse events and number of subjects experiencing adverse events.Assessment of heterogeneity,subgroup analysis and sensitivity analysis were also performed.RESULTS A total of 46 trials on 29TCHMs(3522patients)were included.45 studies were RCTs and 1was CCT.In these 45 RCTs,only 2were appraised as adequately randomised.5of 46 trials were appraised as having low risk of bias in blinding.Sample sizes were generally small ranging from 26 to 216with a median of 68.All trials were conducted in China from 1997 to 2013.All 46 studies assessed cognition using one or a combination of the following scales:MMSE(n=40 studies;3096 patients),HDS(n=22;1664 patients),ADAS-Cog(n=4;241 patients),CDT(n=1;60patients)and CCSE(n=1;26patients).Half of the studies assessed daily function using either the ADL(n=22;1743 patients)or IADL(n=2;203patients).Only 6studies measured behaviour using the FAQ(n=3;226 subjects),BBS(n=1;48patients),NPI(n=1;100subjects)or Neurological Deficits Function Scale(n=1;91patients).30 studies measured global performance.31 of 46 studies made conclusions regarding the safety of the TCHMs.Despite the problems of methodology and reporting,we can identify three TCHMs-NaoXinTong,Shenfu and Tongxinluo as having relatively stronger evidence of efficacy.There is weak evidence for the safety of TCHMs for VaD.CONCLUSION There is weak evidence for the efficacy and safety of TCHMs for VaD because of the poor methodology,short duration of follow-up and inadequate reporting.However the agents appear to be relatively free of severe short-term AEs,hence we encourage further better designed and reported trials. OBJECTIVE To systematically review the clinical efficacy and safety on TCHMs that are used for vascular dementia (VaD). METHODS To identify studies for systematical review, electronic searches were performed through several databases - ALOIS, CNKI, CBM, Weipu, Wanfang, etc. Only randomized control trials (RCTs) or controlled clinical trials (CCTs) were included. Patients were diagnosed with VaD by diagnostic criteria (DSM, NINDS-AIREN, ICD or HIS) as well as imaging technique (CT, MRI or functional imaging, etc) .Eligible TCHMs must be recognized in the Chinese Pharmacopeia or the National Essential Drug List of the People’s Republic of China.Included studies were appraised using the Cochrane Collaboration risk-of-bias criteria. Efficacy and safety outcomes were evaluated by meta-analysis .Efficacy statements include cognition, daily function, global performance and behavior; safety was assessed by the number of adverse events and number of subjects experiencing adverse events. Assessment of heterogeneity, subgroup analysis and sensitivity analysis were also performed .RESULTS A total of 46 trials on 29TCHMs (3522patients) were included.45 studies were RCTs and 1was CCT. These 45 RCTs, only 2were appraised as adequately randomized.5of 46 trials were appraised as having low risk of bias in blinding. Sample sizes were generally small ranging from 26 to 216 with a median of 68. All trials were conducted in China from 1997 to 2013.All 46 studies assessed of using one or a combination of the following scales: MMSE (n = 40 studies; 3096 patients), HDS (n = 22; 1664 patients), ADAS-Cog (n = 4; 241 patients), CDT (n = 1; 60patients) and CCSE the studies assess daily using either the ADL (n = 22; 1743 patients) or IADL (n = 2; 203 patients) .Only 6studies measured behavior using the FAQ (n = 3; 226 subjects) ), NPI (n = 1; 100subjects) or Neurological Deficits Function Scale (n = 1; 91patients) .30 studies measured global performance.31 of 46 studies made conclusions regarding the safety of the TCHMs.Despite the problems of methodology and reporting, we can identify three TCHMs-NaoXinTong, Shenfu and Tongxinluo as having weak stronger of of efficacy. There is weak evidence for the safety of TCHMs for VaD .CONCLUSION There is weak evidence for the efficacy and safety of TCHMs for VaD because of the poor methodology, short duration of follow-up and inadequate reporting. Despite the agents appear to be relatively free of severe short-term AEs, therefore we even better better designed and reported trials.
其他文献
主要演员表:  蔡达标:真功夫原董事长  潘敏峰:蔡达标前妻  潘宇海:蔡达标前小舅子  蔡慧亭:蔡达标与潘敏峰之女  自从2008年前后真功夫爆发的内讧发酵,到真功夫原董事长蔡达标犯职务侵占罪和挪用资金罪终审获刑,真功夫内乱的故事,总算在2014年的这个夏天尘埃落定了。家族内斗,母女反目,前妻亲手把自己曾经深爱的男人送进监狱。一出上好的真人版现实题材经典家庭伦理剧,当然要从头说起。  剧情的开头
中国石油化工股份有限公司浙江石油分公司始建于1950年,1990年定名为浙江省石油总公司。根据国务院机构改革方案规定,1998年8月,浙江省石油总公司及省内各市、县石油公司成
老徐,何许人也?徐永宽呗。在大丰市方圆15平方公里的大桥镇只要一提到镇司法助理员徐永宽,可谓是无人不知,无人不晓。司法行政工作刚恢复的那年,老徐从部队转业,服从组织的
随着丰田一枝独秀地称霸全球汽车业,几乎全世界制造业都在学习丰田生产方式(TPS,Toyota’s Production System,也称精益管理)。  “中国制造”更是争先恐后。据不完全统计:在中国,汽车业及其上下游产业链几乎所有的企业都在推行TPS;在电子电器等行业,也有近一半的企业在学习或已把学习TPS纳入企业的下一步规划。其它行业只要上规模的制造企业,正在培训、推行TPS的也比比皆是。  
“挑剔型”玛丽苏  陈珊在汉口一家广告公司就职,不可否认她长得漂亮,也很会打扮,同事常常恭维她的穿着品位,但私底下,没有一个人愿意和她走得太近。  一切源于她太过挑剔。同事一起吃饭,她总是抱怨菜不是太油就是太素。在办公室冲杯咖啡,她也要皱皱眉挑剔水温。即使去别的公司联系业务,回来也要挑出一堆令她不满意的地方。内容可涉及对方办公室冷气不足,前台小姐着装品位差、香水太浓,主管是个色狼,与她握手的时间超
当新西兰前总理詹妮·希普利(Jenny Shipley)女士站在APEC展馆前,看到眼前大地鲜花锦簇、漫天彩球飞舞、蓝天碧海交映生辉时,似乎也看到了亚太经合组织(APEC)的美好前景。这
1概况第五次国际硬质材料科学会议于1995年2月20~24日在美国夏威夷召开,会期5天,来自世界各地17个国家的共110名代表出席了会议(中国有5名代表)。会议共收到学术论文76篇,内容包括
近日,欧洲科学家做的一项调查显示,年龄是影响婚姻稳定的一个关键砝码。英国巴斯大学伊曼纽尔弗拉尼耶博士对1534对情侣进行了一项追踪调查,结果显示,能强有力维系婚姻的最佳情侣模式是男女双方均受过高等教育且无离异史,同时男方比女方年长5岁以上。研究者称,妻子比丈夫小5岁以上是最不容易产生矛盾的年龄组合,他们的离婚率为其他婚姻的1/6。  另外,一项维也纳大学的研究发现,若丈夫比妻子大4~6岁,生育的子
采用国产二手造型线,加以改造.并配套部分新设备,组建成一条造型线。满足生产S195曲轴的需要,年产铸件6000吨以上。提高了我厂的铸造生产能力。 Using domestic second-hand modeling li
卵巢癌确诊时70%已属晚期,治疗困难,虽经数十年努力,但治疗效果仍在原地徘徊。至今有关卵巢癌的治疗仍有一些问题未达统一。手术治疗的时间、方法、切除范围、淋巴清扫、大网