在这些年来的物质化语境中,关于诗歌的作用,关于新诗的成就得失,关于诗歌的各种思潮,关于诗的具体写法,等等问题,虽然不像过去有些时候那样争得面红耳赤,但分歧仍然存在,只不过人们以更加包容的态度对待各种争议,更以创作实践来发表自己的诗歌观点。在当下这样的氛围中,即使有争论,最多也只是“圈子”内的事情,不会引起更广泛的关注。当《星星》诗刊的编辑将 In these materialized contexts of the past years, the role of poetry, the successes and failures of new poetry, the various thoughts on poetry, the specific ways of writing poetry, and so on are not as hard-won as those in the past. Disagreements still exist, except that people treat disputes in a more tolerant manner and publish their views on poetry more creatively. In the present atmosphere, even if there is a dispute, it is only the matter in the “circle”, which will not attract more attention. When “Star” poetry editor will