一郭沫若同志在《宋钘尹文遗著考》(收入《青铜时代》)和《稷下黄老学派的批判》(收入《十批判书》)中,对《管子》书的《心术》上下、《白心》、《内心》等四篇进行了考证,认为它们是宋钘、尹文的著作。近年来一些学者指出《管子》四篇与《庄子》、《荀子》、《韩非子》等先秦文献所述宋钘、尹文的思想虽有相似之词句,但意义并不符合。笔者不揣浅陋,于此再列《管子》四篇与宋尹思想不合之处有二:其一,《荀子·非十 One of Comrade Guo Mo-ruo’s “Heart Surgery” in the “Guan Zi” book, in his “Poems on the Supremacy of Song Wen’s Poetry” (income “bronze age”) and “criticism of the Jiliao Huang Lao school of thought” White heart “,” heart “and other four textual research, that they are Song Yong, Yin Wen’s writings. In recent years, some scholars have pointed out that though there are similar words and phrases in the four articles of Guan Zi and Song Qin and Yin Wen in pre-Qin literature such as Zhuangzi, Xunzi and Hanfeizi, their meanings are not consistent. I do not speculate shallow, here again listed ”tube“ four and the idea of ​​Song Yin does not have two points: First, ”Xunzi non-ten