【裁判要旨】与变更登记不同,设立登记是公司法人格存续的法律基础,判决撤销设立登记是对所有登记事项的全盘否定,将导致公司法人格的消灭。因此,在审理设立登记案件时,不能仅仅考虑设立登记行为本身的合法性,还应当考虑公司、其他股东、员工以及债权人等相关主体的正当利益,以最终实现对原告诉请的适度保护。案号一审:(2011)金行初字第11号【案情】原告:徐旭礼。被告:上海市工商行政管理局 Different from registration of change, the establishment of registration is the legal basis for the survival of corporate personality. The decision to cancel the establishment registration is a total negation of all registration items, which will result in the elimination of corporate personality. Therefore, when hearing the establishment of registration cases, we should not just consider the legitimacy of the registration itself, but also consider the legitimate interests of the relevant parties such as the company, other shareholders, employees and creditors to finally achieve the proper protection of the plaintiff’s appeal. Case No. First instance: (2011) Jin Xing Chu Zi No. 11 【Case】 Plaintiff: Xu Xu ceremony. Defendant: Shanghai Administration for Industry and Commerce