论文部分内容阅读
包寿南同志的《石堡城疑辨》一文,载于《西北史地》一九八二年第一期(以下简称《疑辨》)。该文认为:今卓尼羊巴城就是唐石堡城。他考查和论证问题的方法,即“根据八稜碑的竖碑地点、时间、碑文内容、碑址地形特点及当时临卓一带在唐蕃王朝军事关系的战略地位等”来得出的《疑辨》的结论,在方法论上,我们以为是很有可取之处的。但是,在我们细心拜读《疑辨》之后,觉得对石堡城的地理位置问题,还有值得继续探讨的必要。这里不妨提出我们的一些拙见,以求教于包寿南同志和各位师友。
Comrade Bao Shou-nan’s “Stone Fort City Discrimination,” a document, is contained in “The History and Geography of Northwest China,” the first issue in 1982 (hereinafter referred to as “Discrimination”). The article thinks: This Zhuoni sheep city is Stone Fort Castle. His method of examining and arguing the question was: “According to the” discrimination from the location and time of the erected monument, the content of the etymology, the topographical features of the monument and the strategic status of the then Linzhu area in the military relations of the Tang Dynasty, “In the methodology, we think it is very good for the conclusion. However, after we have carefully read ”Doubtful," we feel the need to continue exploring the location of Stone Fort City. Here may wish to put forward some of our humble opinion in order to learn from Comrade Bao Shou-nan and you mentors.