近年来,关于我军第一面军旗诞生地与设计者问题,国内党史界有些同志提出质疑,认为我军第一面军旗图案、样式的设计人不是何长工、杨立三等人,而是在毛泽东的亲自领导下,由安源军事会议集体设计确定的.当然,如果这种说法不只是分析得出的,而是有当年的文献记载作佐证,我们想,党史界的同志是会赞同的,但是到目前为止,没有看到持这种观点的同志拿得出过硬的佐证材料,我们也未发现当年文献材料中有这样记载.在这种情况下,笔者认为,认定第一面军旗的诞生地和设计者,只能依据当事人的回忆.当事人是怎样回忆这个问题的呢?时任工农革命军第一军第一师师部参谋处参谋的何长工在《秋收起义和工农革命军》一文中回忆道:“……旗子和袖章的图案还是杨立三与我设计的,在修水请人按图案雕刻好的”.时任师部参谋处处长的陈树华1985年6月4日在接受修水县委党史办干部采访时说:“我同参谋长钟文璋在一个办公室办公,加上何长工同志才成三人,为了计 In recent years, regarding the birthplace and designer of the first flag of our army, some comrades in the history of the party in the country have questioned that the design of the pattern and style of the flag on the first side of our army is not made by any permanent worker, Under the leadership of Mao Zedong and collective design of the Anyuan military conference, of course, if such an argument is not merely an analysis, but an evidence of the current year’s record, we think that comrades in the party’s history will agree However, up till now, we have not seen such evidence from the comrades who took this view and we did not find any such records in the documents of that year. In this case, the author believes that finding the flag of the first side The birthplace and designer, can only be based on the parties’ memories.How do the parties recall this problem? He Ren Gong workers and peasants Revolutionary Army First Army Division Staff General Staff He Chang workers in the “Autumn Harvest Uprising and the Workers and Peasants Revolutionary Army ”Recalled one article:“ ... ... the flag and the armband design or Yang Lisan and I design, repair water, please people according to the pattern carved good. ”When the division chief of staff Chen Shuhua June 4, 1985 at accept Xichang County Party History Office cadre interview said: "I and Chief of Staff Zhong Wenzhang in an office work, together with Comrade He Changgong only three people, in order to count