《带灯》一出,洛阳纸贵,在读书界和评论界可谓好评如潮。笔者想根据自己的阅读感受与思考,对《带灯》提出几点批评意见,并借此与一些著名的批评观点进行商榷。《带灯》的问题在于,在小说人物的一系列矛盾冲突中,作者把立场或者说同情心显然放到了权力的一边,放到了强者的一边。在涉及公平、正义以及人的尊严等问题上,一个作家应该直面现实,而不应该闲笔历史,作家的良知不应该游移,更不应模糊了这两者的界限。 “With a lamp,” a Luoyang paper expensive, praised in the book industry and critics. According to my own reading feelings and thinking, I want to put forward some criticisms on the “lantern”, and to discuss with some famous criticisms. The problem with “light” is that in a series of contradictions and conflicts between novels and characters, the author clearly places his position or compassion on the power side and the strong man side. On the issues of fairness, justice and human dignity, a writer should face the truth instead of giving up his history. The conscience of the writer should not wander, let alone blur the boundary between the two.