本文研究了用带电粒子束代替火炮和导弹的防空系统对付反舰导弹所带来的战术结果。“弹药”供应不再是一个问题,瞄准可能不再需要那么精确;甚至作战部队本身的组成亦要起变化。但是,有一个问题比这些问题更为重要——即这个系统将会成功呢,或者它仅仅是一种可望而不可及的东西呢? In this paper, the tactical results of anti-ship missiles against the anti-ship missiles using air-defense systems with charged particle beams instead of artillery and missiles are studied. The supply of “ammunition” is no longer a problem, and targeting may no longer be as precise as possible; even the composition of the combat force itself needs to change. But one issue is more important than these questions - is the system going to succeed, or is it just an elusive thing?