论文部分内容阅读
【裁判要旨】建设方承诺提供住房但所供房屋不符合使用功能,居住人因自行维修而造成伤害的,应认定其为无因管理人,雇主和建设方未尽到安全保障义务。受益者——建设方和雇主应对此承担相应赔偿责任。案号一审:(2010)丹民初字第2692号二审:(2011)镇民终字第128号【案情】原告(被上诉人):石锁龙。被告(被上诉人):张雷静。被告(上诉人):阜阳市颖州区众鑫新型墙体材料厂(以下简称阜阳材料厂)。2008年8月30日,宿舍漏雨,原告石锁龙爬上被告阜阳材料厂提供的窑室加接工地的宿舍屋顶进行修缮。屋顶石棉瓦断裂,原告坠地受伤。经查明,原告作业处的窑室加接工程系张雷静从阜阳材料厂处承接,原告受张雷静雇佣在该工程处做瓦工。原告修理的房屋
[Referee summary] The construction party promises to provide housing but the house is not in conformity with the usage function, and the resident is harmed due to self-maintenance, it shall be deemed as not due to the administrator, employer and construction party did not fulfill the obligation of safety and security. Beneficiaries - Constructor and employer should bear the corresponding compensation liability. Case No. First instance: (2010) Dan Min Chu Zi No. 2692 Second instance: (2011) Zhenmin Zhong Zi No. 128 【Case】 The plaintiff (appellee): Shi lock dragon. Defendant (appellee): Zhang Lei Jing. Defendant (appellant): Yingxin District, Fuyang City Zhongxin new wall materials plant (hereinafter referred to Fuyang Material Factory). On August 30, 2008, dormitories leaking, the plaintiff stone dragon climbed up to the defendant Fuyang Materials Factory provided the kiln room plus the dormitory roof renovation site. Asbestos roof tiles rupture, the plaintiff fell to the ground injured. It has been ascertained that Zhang Lei Jing, a kiln chamber joint engineering department of the Plaintiff’s Operations Department, undertook the work from Fuyang Materials Factory and the plaintiff was hired by Zhang Lei Jing to work as a bricklayer at the Agency. The plaintiff repaired the house