,Critical review of the use and scientific basis of forensic gait analysis

来源 :法庭科学研究 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:dong_0622
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
This review summarizes the scientific basis of forensic gait analysis and evaluates its use in the Netherlands,United Kingdom and Denmark,following recent critique on the admission of gait evidence in Canada. A useful forensic feature is (1) measurable,(2) consistent within and (3) different between individuals. Reviewing the academic literature,this article found that (1) forensic gait features can be quantified or observed from surveillance video,but research into accuracy,validity and reliability of these methods is needed; (2) gait is variable within individuals under differing and constant circumstances,with speed having major influence; (3) the discriminative strength of gait features needs more research,although clearly variation exists between individuals. Nevertheless,forensic gait analysis has contributed to several criminal trials in Europe in the past 15 years. The admission of gait evidence differs between courts. The methods are mainly observer-based: multiple gait analysts (independently) assess gait features on video footage of a perpetrator and suspect. Using gait feature databases,likelihood ratios of the hypotheses that the observed individuals have the same or another identity can be calculated. Automated gait recognition algorithms calculate a difference measure between video clips,which is compared with a threshold value derived from a video gait recognition database to indicate likelihood. However,only partly automated algorithms have been used in practice. We argue that the scientific basis of forensic gait analysis is limited. However,gait feature databases enable its use in court for supportive evidence with relatively low evidential value. The recommendations made in this review are (1) to expand knowledge on inter- and intra-subject gait variabilities,discriminative strength and interdependency of gait features,method accuracies,gait feature databases and likelihood ratio estimations; (2) to compare automated and observer-based gait recognition methods; to design (3) an inteational standard method with known validity,reliability and proficiency tests for analysts; (4) an inteational standard gait feature data collection method resulting in database(s); (5) (inter)national guidelines for the admission of gait evidence in court; and (6) to decrease the risk for cognitive and contextual bias in forensic gait analysis. This is expected to improve admission of gait evidence in court and judgment of its evidential value. Several ongoing research projects focus on parts of these recommendations.
其他文献
师范院校的学生是未来的教师,他们的思想道德水平,直接影响下一代孩子。因此,加强对学生的德育教育是至关重要的。那么,如何在英语教学中加强德育教育呢?本文从两方面进行了
人口与住宅休戚相关。以人为本,依据区域内人口变化的情况,及时研究、调整住房相关政策,完善住房建设与管理制度,不断改善人民群众的居住条件,是政府部门一项十分重要工作职
摘 要:传媒手段和信息技术的迅猛发展,数字化传媒逐渐成为传媒主流。纸质媒体数字化,声像媒体数字化,以及后继的网络媒体、手机媒体等等。随着传播技术手段以数字制式全面替代传统模拟制式的变化,适应数字传媒的档案信息数字化建设刻不容缓。  关键词:档案信息数字;数字传媒;传媒手段  数字化的存储与传输是用于数字传媒海量信息所必不可少的,然而对于档案信息的利用方式也是以数字化诉求为主体。所以,在对数字化信息
本文通过对目前英语教师跨文化意识的现状分析,探讨了新时期我国高校英语教师跨文化意识培养的必要性和可行性,提出了培养跨文化意识的策略,即英语教师要不断地更新教育观念
摘 要:在图书馆专业分馆的管理中,个性化服务是实现图书馆信息纵向发展的重要手段。其服务宗旨是了解用户信息需求,并利用现代的科技手段实现针对性服务,使图书馆的管理达到更加完善的境界。  关键词:图书馆;专业分馆;个性化信息服务  个性化的信息服务是针对用户的信息使用习惯及偏好,向用户提供个性化服务的方式。这种个性化,就是针对用户的独特需求向其提供具有针对性的服务。用户对信息的需求有所不同,将信息过滤
英语学习在我国可谓受到举国重视。学好英语,把英语学习提升至兴趣范畴是英语学习者的最高境界。在中国英语学习给人们带来的困扰主要原因是英语学习能力弱,方式方法有偏差。
摘 要:在我国的体育训练中,羽毛球是体育课程的重要组成部分,对羽毛球训练方式方法的改善和提高能够促进羽毛球课程的进步和发展。青少年的羽毛球步法练习是提高运动技术的关键,羽毛球的步法有很多种。青少年要对羽毛球步法的训练引起重视,因为实践证明,经过训练与非训练的学员在技术水平上有明显的差别。本文对青少年羽毛球的步法灵敏性训练进行分析。  关键词:青少年;羽毛球;步法;灵敏性  羽毛球是一种集速度、力量
人脸图像在实际采集过程中会严重受光照条件变化的影响,本文围绕复杂光照问题展开,在ORL人脸库和Yale B人脸库采用2DPCA+2DDWT算法提取复杂光照条件下的人脸图像特征,验证其鲁棒性。
本文从介绍职业技能竞赛开始,阐述职业技能竞赛对职业院校课程开发的重要意义,并进一步探讨以职业技能竞赛为平台的课程开发的原则和方法。 This article starts with the i
摘 要:中小企业往往把管理重点聚集在销售数量和销售利润方面,对市场营销带来的风险管理重视程度不足,因此造成多年来辛苦创造的品牌受损。本文首先阐述市场营销风险管理的成因以及可能造成的风险,进而分析不同类型市场营销风险带来的后果,最后提出风险防范和控制策略。  关键词:市场营销;风险管理;产品风险;销售风险  一、市场营销风险的含义和风险内容  1.市场营销风险管理含义  市场营销风险是指企业在开展市