总体而言,《清史稿·忠义传》叙事条理清晰、重点突出、注重细节,这些均值得肯定;但也存在主次不分、详略失当、记事不实、人名讹误等问题。此外,官绅于死难前杀死妻女一事,掺杂了传主某些自私和功利的因素,置于《忠义传》中是否妥当,值得斟酌。 In general, the clear, focused and attention-giving narratives in “The History of the Qing Dynasty Manuscripts and Loyalty Contributions” all deserved to be affirmed. However, there are also some problems such as primary and secondary misconduct, miscalculations, misrepresentation of personal names, and corrupt personal names. In addition, it is worth considering that the gentry should kill some of his wives and daughters before his death, mixed up with some elements of selfishness and utilitarianism, and put them in the Loyalty and Righteousness Biography.